Tuesday, July 08, 2008

Pervasiveness of Virtual Directories?

Does anyone know what the actual market penetration of virtual directories is? How many mid to large sized organizations actually use a virtual directory in their infrastructure? With all the debate on virtual directory vs. metadirectory recently in the blogosphere, one of Nishant's comments caught me off guard, when he was responding to Matt's statement that there "...has been a ground swell of apps that directly support Active Directory as the user store":

"And how are more applications supporting AD anyway? A lot of that has to do with the emergence of Virtual Directory solutions. A number of applications in the Oracle stable today claim to support AD as the identity store. The mechanism for all these is moving to Virtual Directory NOT because Oracle has a Virtual Directory product, but because maintaining adapters/connectors/plugins and what have you for all LDAP variants is a colossal nightmare."

Woah...that is a a huge claim there. Is it possible that the "groundwell of apps that directory support Active Directory" is due to "emergence of Virtual Directory solutions"?
Although I usually find what Nishant has to say as thought provoking, and the fact that every organization should be running a virtual directory solution is pretty evident by now, that claim sounds pretty absurd to me. What are the actual market numbers of the virtual directory solutions in production? (I know Radicati had some numbers around this, although I haven't gotten my hands on the paper yet.) Now compare that to the number of companies running AD. Even without the numbers, I think that Nishant is way off here. App support for AD is due to its undeniable pervasiveness, not because of the emergence of virtual directory technology.

Jeff Bohren has some interesting comments on the same post. Check it out.


NishantK said...

Good catch on what I said. I think I mis-stated what I was trying to say. I didn't mean to imply that the current groundswell is due to Virtual Directory. I meant that the coming deluge will have a large Virtual Directory component to it.

I posted a clarification on my position to my blog. Check it out and provide your thoughts: http://blogs.oracle.com/talkingidentity/2008/07/to_ad_or_not_to_ad.html

Ashraf Motiwala said...

Thanks for the clarification, Nishant.

Alisha said...


I'm Alisha from Wowzio, and I'm excited to tell you about our new widget platform that helps bloggers increase readership by providing engaging widgets containing your blog's rich content. You can check out widgets customized for your blog here:

Wowzio Widgets for your Blog

I wanted to reach out to you to ask for your feedback on these widgets (feel free to install them on your blog, if you feel they are a good fit). I'm sorry for leaving this message via a comment, it's not at all our intent to spam you ( which is why i'm leaving this comment on an older post and you can always remove this comment ). Again, we would love to hear your feedback.

Alisha Wright

sexy said...